Files
BZJZ_Material/文档润色流和知识库构建流/claude-scholar/skills/nature-polishing/references/phrasebank-playbook.md
2026-06-11 03:33:14 +08:00

3.6 KiB

Phrasebank Playbook

Use this file after the main argument and section role are already clear. It is a phrasebank layer derived from Academic Phrasebank, not a substitute for deciding what the paragraph is trying to do.

Evidence strength

Choose verbs that match the evidence.

Strong

  • show
  • demonstrate
  • establish
  • reveal
  • identify

Use only when the design and data justify a strong claim.

Moderate

  • suggest
  • indicate
  • support the view that
  • are consistent with
  • point to

Use when the interpretation is plausible but not definitive.

Speculative

  • may reflect
  • could arise from
  • appears to
  • seems likely
  • might be explained by

Use when moving beyond direct observation.

Evidence collocations

Adjectives for evidence:

  • weak: limited, scant, insufficient
  • developing: growing, emerging, accumulating
  • strong: robust, reliable, convincing, considerable

Useful patterns:

  • The evidence presented here suggests that ...
  • The available evidence supports the view that ...
  • Current evidence raises important questions about ...
  • The data point to a need for ...

Transition families

Contrast

  • however
  • by contrast
  • nevertheless
  • despite this
  • whereas

Addition

  • furthermore
  • in addition
  • moreover
  • also

Consequence

  • therefore
  • thus
  • consequently
  • as a result
  • thereby

Qualification

  • notably
  • importantly
  • approximately
  • in part
  • at least in this cohort

Prefer the smallest connective that does the job. Do not decorate every sentence with a transition word.

Paragraph linking without sounding repetitive

Prefer these patterns over repeated This suggests:

  • restate the noun: Such heterogeneity ...
  • definite noun phrase: The resulting gradient ...
  • participial summary: Taken together, ...
  • zero-connective progression when the logic is already obvious

Limit demonstrative-led openings. One per paragraph is usually enough.

Gap language

Use gap statements that are precise rather than dramatic:

  • remains poorly understood
  • has not been examined in ...
  • has received limited attention
  • few studies have addressed ...
  • evidence remains sparse for ...

Avoid:

  • no one has ever studied
  • completely unknown
  • ignored by all previous work

Comparison with prior work

To align with earlier work:

  • These results are consistent with ...
  • This finding accords with ...
  • Our observations broadly support ...

To mark divergence fairly:

  • In contrast to earlier reports, ...
  • This finding differs from ...
  • One possible reason for this discrepancy is ...

Limitation language

Useful patterns:

  • These findings should be interpreted with caution because ...
  • A limitation of this study is that ...
  • The generalisability of these results is limited by ...
  • We cannot exclude the possibility that ...
  • Another source of uncertainty is ...

Pair limitation language with the actual source of uncertainty, not with vague modesty.

Implication language

Useful patterns:

  • An implication of this is that ...
  • These findings may help to explain ...
  • These data support further investigation of ...
  • This work has implications for ...

Implications should stay within the evidence boundary.

Future-work language

Useful patterns:

  • Further work is needed to determine whether ...
  • Future studies should examine ...
  • A useful next step would be to ...
  • Larger studies are required to validate ...

Future work should emerge from an actual limitation, uncertainty, or opportunity.