TWBG_Materials/文档润色流和知识库构建流/claude-scholar/skills/paper-self-review/examples/example-self-review.md

Paper Self-Review Example

Verdict

• needs moderate revision

Blocking issues

1. Main claim is not tied to a statistical test.
2. Baseline comparison is missing one obvious prior system.
3. Figure 2 caption does not explain the metric.

Non-blocking issues

• abstract can quantify the gain more clearly
• discussion should name one concrete limitation