BZJZ_Material/文档润色流和知识库构建流/claude-scholar/skills/publication-chart-skill/examples/08-review-existing-figure-or-table.md

Example 8 — Review an existing figure or table draft

User-style prompt

Here is my current results figure screenshot and the draft benchmark table. Please tell me what is weak, whether the figure should stay a figure or become a figure + table pair, and give me the recommended pubfig/pubtab revision path.

Expected skill interpretation

• artifact: review / revision
• maturity: existing deliverable upgrade
• structure: figure-only or figure + companion table
• goal: keep the strongest communication role for each artifact instead of polishing a weak form blindly

Preferred route

• inspect the current figure/table role split first
• recommend whether the figure should stay visual and the table should preserve exact values
• use pubfig for the figure revision and pubtab for the table revision when both are needed

Minimum acceptable output shape

• identify the concrete publication weaknesses in the current artifact(s)
• say whether the final deliverable should be figure-only, table-only, or figure + table
• provide one runnable pubfig and/or pubtab revision route
• define explicit export filenames and a short QA checklist